April 2025 Gleanings
Now in its 59th year, your Big Island Press Club is still going strong! We're a nonprofit, and our continuing mission is to promote openness in government and grow new journalists to keep us informed -- needed now more than ever. Our monthly board meetings are continuing via Zoom, and all members can attend our next one at 9 a.m. Saturday, May 10, by using this link: https://hawaii.zoom.us/j/85950719889 . Questions? contact Secretary Nancy Cook Lauer at nclauer@gmail.com
President's Message
I’m writing to you on the heels of our Scholarship Committee selecting several worthwhile individuals to receive $6,000 in scholarship funds from our Big Island Press Club Foundation. I’m looking forward to introducing them to you at our planned May 8 scholarship dinner at Restaurant Kenichi in Hilo.
I sure hope the prospect of meeting young people intent on furthering this profession will motivate you to buy your ticket to our planned dinner!
Otherwise, you might be interested in our guest speaker, Chelsea Davis, of Hawai`i News Now. Our very own board member Maya-Lin Green noted how Davis loves to tell local stories, and how she pulls at heart strings with her Instagram post recalling her Lahaina vigil coverage. It will be nice to hear from a passionate young Hawaii storyteller on a night honoring scholars who want to get into the business of telling stories.
I look forward to seeing you before we all get into summer mode — with a state of mind or a venturing off on summer adventures, wherever they may be.
Your president and Scholarship Committee chairwoman Tiffany E Hunt
P.S. Mahalo to Bob Duerr and John Burnett for your work on the Scholarship Committee. It takes a village to make a village and your volunteerism is very much appreciated (and needed).
Scholarship dinner ticket deadline is May 1.
$30 for members, $35 for guests
5:30-8:30 p.m., Thursday May 8
Tickets are available on the BIPC website: https://www.bigislandpressclub.org/collect/description/556042-z-big-island-press-club-scholarship-dinner
As well as Eventbrite: https://BIPCscholarshipdinner.eventbrite.com
Island Intelligencer: U.S. surrenders in the information war
By J.P. ATWELL The Island Intelligencer
Most of us islanders enjoy the bliss of ignorance about the underworld — espionage against our nation, organized crime in our cities, assassinations on U.S. soil by foreign adversaries. There is, however, one element of the Dark Side that touches us all, even in paradise — the information war. It is subtle, long-standing, ongoing, has covert and overt elements, and pits Western ideals (freedom, democracy) against others, like Russia and China’s communism, Iran’s militant theocracy, or India’s religious nationalism.
That said, Washington last month began disarming our nation’s frontline fighters in this conflict. Tasked with carrying pro-democracy and pro-Western messaging into denied areas and hostile territory, they sit on the chopping block — Radio Free Asia, Radio Free Europe, the Office of Cuba Broadcasting, Middle East Broadcasting Network, the Voice of America and the Open Technology Fund (which provides uncensored internet access to people living under repressive regimes).
ADVERTISING
Called “the hard edge” of U.S. soft power, and fighting fascism and communism throughout the 20th century, their effectiveness is proven by the amount of money that adversaries spend trying to block them. Consider that VOA alone broadcasts in 50 languages and reaches a target audience of 345 million listeners. The platforms penetrate the intangible, darkest corners of our globe’s ideological worlds — Central Asia, tribal regions of South Asia, North Korea — and are infinitely cheaper than physical weapons needed when ideological conflicts move onto physical battlefields.
This follows another recent administration decision to dismantle our nation’s defensive units in the same conflict, ones that monitor and counter adversaries’ anti-American messaging, agitprop and propaganda aimed at influencing our foreign policies and elections.
ADVERTISING
Since January, the State Department’s Global Engagement Center, Homeland Security’s CISA and FBI’s Foreign Influence Task Force have shuttered or redirected, and federal funding for private entities, like Stanford’s Internet Observatory, stopped. Others, like Indiana University’s Observatory on Social Media (which analyzes misinformation and social media manipulation), are under attack by administration supporters, and the White House dismantled a multi-agency effort led by the National Security Council to monitor Russia’s increasingly aggressive propaganda efforts in the U.S.
We are waving a white flag on the AI battlefield, too. The administration recently removed from its AI doctrine “misinformation” as something that needs to be guarded against. Meanwhile, Moscow brags about efforts to infect Western AI platforms with pro-Russia narratives, and the recent release of China’s DeepSeek chatbot showcases how oppressive governments can distort information provided by AI models.
Cold Warriors, psychological operations veterans, spooks, foreign policy wonks, advocates of soft power diplomacy and foreign allies are scratching their heads over the U.S. surrender. The administration’s limited attempts at explanation — finger-pointing at unnamed leftist forces and other unsubstantiated claims — ring hollow. Meanwhile, Havana, Beijing and Moscow have, in press releases, publicly cheered the U.S. withdrawal from the information conflict (without laying down their weapons).
There is an information civil war, too. 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue and the Defense Department are now, in an unprecedented manner, controlling which news outlets have access to reporting on players and policies, with a clear preference for outlets that provide favorable reporting and providing newsmaker amateurs with seats at tables once reserved for professionally-trained journalists subject to well-established editorial processes. Our president has also started labeling as “illegal” outlets that document his policies and actions in anything but a favorable light, reflecting modern authoritarians like Hungary’s Viktor Orban.
Meanwhile, administration financial backers are manipulating the public’s access to information. Jeff Bezos is using his purchase of our nation’s capital’s most prominent newspaper — the Washington Post — to restrict advertising and opinion pieces that throw shade on the Oval Office.
In response, award-winning journalists and editors have resigned, and patrons have cancelled subscriptions to the 76-time Pulitzer Prize-winning paper, which uncovered the Watergate scandal. Simultaneously, the partisan leanings of the policies of Elon Musk’s X, a top source of “news” for the American public, has led many users to migrate to a different platform, BlueSky; news consumers are voting on information objectivity “with their feet.” (Mind you, the checks-and-balances offered by a free press have long been referred to in our nation as the government’s “fourth branch.”)
It is impossible to spin this story positively and still pass the giggle test. There is no fact-based explanation for how these recent developments can do anything but harm the republic. Our foreign allies and adversaries see it. Why can’t the American people?
(reprinted from the Island Intelligencer https://islandintelligencer.substack.com/ )
J.P. Atwell, a member of the BIPC Board, is a former senior CIA operations officer. His two-decade career began as an intelligence analyst and took him to every continent, save Antarctica. He now calls Hawaii Island home. He welcomes your comments at island.intelligencer@gmail.com.
2025 Big Island Press Club Board
Please feel free to contact any board members with your suggestions, or if you wish to volunteer!
President: Tiffany Edwards Hunt, former journalist, middle school teacher
newswoman@mac.com
Vice President: Jim Wilson, retired publisher, Hawaii Tribune-Herald jimwilsonvolcanocottage@gmail.com
Secretary: Nancy Cook Lauer, retired journalist, blogger www.allhawaiinews.com <nclauer@gmail.com>
Treasurer: Robert Duerr, filmmaker and journalist, Hawaii Fishing News <surf77@me.com>
Immediate Past President: John Burnett, journalist, Tribune-Herald <jburnett@hawaiitribuneherald.com>
Director: Patsy Iwasaki, professor, University of Hawaii-Hilo
<piwasaki@hawaii.edu>
Director: John Atwell, former CIA Senior Operations Officer, columnist, editor <jno.p.atwell@gmail.com>
Director: Maya-Lin Green, education and communications team member, Pacific Islands Climate Adaptation Science Center <mlgreen@hawaii.edu>
Director: Megan Moseley, journalist, reporter for Maui News <mm321606@ohio.edu>
Director Emeritus: Ross Wilson, PR, Current Events rossw@current-events.com
